Home Insurance in Indiana — from $35/mo Start
SafexQuotes logo

Rental Property Insurance for Landlords in Indiana

Compare Indiana landlord insurance — protect your rental investment.

No fees. No obligations. Soft check only.

Home Insurance in Indiana illustration

We work with top companies to find the best match for you!

  • Geico logo
  • Progressive logo
  • Allstate logo
  • Liberty Mutual logo
  • Safeco Insurance logo
  • Travelers logo
  • Nation General logo
  • Amica logo
  • Foremost Insurance Group logo
  • Mutual Of Enumclaw Insurance logo
  • American Modern logo
  • Pemco logo
  • USAA logo
  • Carrier 14 logo
  • Farmers Insurance logo
  • American Family Insurance logo
  • Nationwide logo
  • MetLife Insurance logo
  • Carrier 19 logo
  • Esurance logo
  • Dairyland Insurance logo
  • Mapfre Insurance logo
  • Stillwater Insurance Group logo
  • The Hartford logo
  • Encompass logo
  • The General Insurance logo
  • Geico logo
  • Progressive logo
  • Allstate logo
  • Liberty Mutual logo
  • Safeco Insurance logo
  • Travelers logo
  • Nation General logo
  • Amica logo
  • Foremost Insurance Group logo
  • Mutual Of Enumclaw Insurance logo
  • American Modern logo
  • Pemco logo
  • USAA logo
  • Carrier 14 logo
  • Farmers Insurance logo
  • American Family Insurance logo
  • Nationwide logo
  • MetLife Insurance logo
  • Carrier 19 logo
  • Esurance logo
  • Dairyland Insurance logo
  • Mapfre Insurance logo
  • Stillwater Insurance Group logo
  • The Hartford logo
  • Encompass logo
  • The General Insurance logo

About Rental Property in Indiana

Indianapolis's growing rental market makes landlord insurance essential for Indiana property investors. DP-3 policies cover the dwelling, fixtures, liability, and lost rental income.

Indiana's affordable property values mean landlord insurance rates are among the most accessible in the country — typically $35–$65/month per property.

Comparing carriers reveals 20–30% rate differences for identical coverage.

Indiana landlord? Standard homeowners won't cover your rental property

Get Midwest Value Coverage plans starting at $35/mo

Compare Quotes Now

Customer Satisfaction & Complaint Score breakdown

Real-world claim and customer experience indicators from widely recognized insurers.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does IN landlord insurance cover?

Dwelling, fixtures, liability, lost rental income from covered events.

Cost in Indiana?

$35–$65/month per property.

Homeowners for a rental?

No. Non-occupied properties need landlord (DP-3) insurance.

Tenant damage covered?

Covered perils yes; wear-and-tear no.

Lost rent covered?

Yes. Fair rental income coverage included.

What customers say

★★★★★

"First-time homeowner — got my insurance sorted before closing with no stress."

Tom H.

Nashville, TN

★★★★★

"Bundled home and auto and saved almost $400/year. Wish I'd done it sooner."

Diane M.

Portland, OR

★★★★★

"Compared condo insurance plans side by side. Never realized how much rates vary between carriers."

Marcus J.

Boston, MA

Trustpilot logo
Excellent
892 reviews View